beta

You're viewing our new website - find out more

Publication - Consultation Responses

Designation of a seal haul-out site in the Ythan Estuary: analysis of consultation responses

Published: 30 Sep 2016

Analysis of responses to the consultation on the proposal to designate a seal haul-out site.

31 page PDF

2.0MB

31 page PDF

2.0MB

Contents
Designation of a seal haul-out site in the Ythan Estuary: analysis of consultation responses
Annex 1

31 page PDF

2.0MB

Annex 1

The table below outlines the consultation responses reviewed by Marine Scotland. Full responses from organisations and individuals who gave their permission to publish are available online.

Respondent group

Individuals

Submission reference number

Anonymous

Elaine Fathers

James Hutcheon

Anonymous

Patricia Tricker

Anonymous

Mark Hesketh

Ian Black

Louise Holmes

Anonymous

Anonymous

David Hawkins

Anonymous

Nora Pirie

Anonymous

Anonymous

A N Cairney

G W Souter

Anonymous

Caroline Thomson

C Bain

Anonymous

Ron Macdonald

Anonymous

Stephen Evans

Phyllus Hesketh

Anonymous

Anonymous

Rosalind Cuthill

Anonymous

Jacqueline Scoular

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

George Wallace

Anonymous

Esther Sutherland

Gordon Lodger

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Alan F Renaud

Professor Charles Weir

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

S G Taylor

Anonymous

Anonymous

Derek Pake

M Newbiggin

Anonymous

Anonymous

Kenneth Murray

John Duffus

Charles Catto

Jeremy Hopkins

I S Francis

Anonymous

Anonymous

Alexander Taylor

William Barron Campbell

Anthony Griffin

Anonymous

Professor Jeremy Cresswell

Jen Strachan

Anonymous

Anonymous

Frances Morrison

Thomas and Anne Whalley

Anonymous

Andrew Coventry

Anonymous

George Kindness

Harry Bickerstaff

Dr Andrew Walker

Anonymous

Martin Cheyne

Anonymous

Anonymous

Ruairidh Cooper

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Karen Clements

Anonymous

Anonymous

Martyn Gorman

Anonymous

Anonymous

E Laver

C M Elliott

Anonymous

William M McDonald

Malcolm Lamont

Anonymous

Nicola Robb

Anonymous

Nicola Twine

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Debra Storr

Kenneth Mackenzie

Lorraine Rae

Anonymous

Jane Bradford

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

William Taylor

Bryan Garden

Anonymous

Ian McColl

Anonymous

Sue Edwards

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Glen Douglas

Fred Middlebrook

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Peter Morrison

Andrew Wilkie

Anonymous

Tim Marshall

Shelley Jonnstone

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Irene Taylor

Anonymous

Anonymous

Steven Cooper

Anonymous

V Easton

Mark Murray

Ian Still

Valerie Banks

Anonymous

Anonymous

Alexander Watson

A Bisset

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Lindsay Allardyce

Philip Sellar

Anonymous

Anonymous

J Boyle

Eilidh Watson

Anonymous

Anonymous

Debra Storr

Anonymous

Andrew Maclean

Anonymous

George Clements

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Kirsty Houston

Gavin McGrath

Lorraine Pollock

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Ewen Cameron

Anonymous

Alex Davidson

Rebecca Rae

Kenneth Chalmers

Pat Smith

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Dr William Church

Anonymous

Iain Smith

Anonymous

David Hardie

Anonymous

Duncan McRae

Anonymous

Sarah Peacock

Walter Innes

Anonymous

Philip Kenyon

David Fry

Chris York

Gordon Mason

Katherine Kennedy

Anonymous

Anonymous

Jill Rennie

C Smith

Robert McClymont

Anonymous

Anonymous

Stephen Baillie

Anonymous

PD Brown

Michael Michael J.W.

Lorraine Gosling

Raymond Davidson

Harry Webster

Anonymous

David Lumsden

Niall McKillop

Ross Flett

William Laver

Anonymous

Anonymous

Raymond Kenyon

Anonymous

Professor Nigel H Trewin

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Douglas Stewart

C M Elliott

Anonymous

Ewan Clark

Louise Clark

Anonymous

Anonymous

Tom Gordon

Anonymous

Gordon Porter

J Murray

J Main

Anonymous

Anonymous

Alexander Barelle

Anonymous

Fred Hay

Mr Hugh Hodge

Anonymous

Anonymous

Theresa Ritchie

Sam Griffin

Dr Trevor Hastings

Anonymous

Anonymous

Dr R L Walker

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

Anonymous

4751197

7953569

9081855

9897314

19945659

22346874

22551563

37345069

40363860

40497617

47430014

62553101

67997745

69213888

70746119

72377581

73144082

74689543

75509998

80950027

81399534

82080873

84290034

84971735

86901435

92894906

99219203

104882878

105080075

107498412

108023000

111245954

111520387

123978790

124822376

136978329

138244797

139438373

142273859

145480731

149292671

153502680

155436915

164619315

165858468

166892684

167224623

170685494

174207583

178348297

198636525

202296269

203672201

210463175

212415067

213299767

219202302

219383731

220641730

225862269

225996394

235282935

239303302

248883200

253237623

267003403

267451885

272408862

276680881

280204668

286753501

287730413

290502501

295116820

296418245

298959131

300852601

305498263

307067688

307862121

310525926

317094114

323890846

329251150

330108355

330328078

339946973

353616283

354648636

362870697

367986787

376217815

376457195

378864908

386195344

398674424

402162216

409437499

422173311

422267731

429043455

429120225

429610249

430941235

435052765

436487268

437304998

437599266

447657613

451010538

452174538

455712509

458441987

459796629

462485375

463629336

465256421

468972741

469101297

469891808

474701598

484779920

497497036

506055727

510697095

512666158

513757980

517624475

522605825

528236373

533228160

534116364

535468881

536212472

536403094

546947733

548187916

551254953

553085110

553283924

565312557

568517340

571596631

572180947

576656349

577520109

600447535

602256191

605598816

608246381

615260222

616510756

616975917

621373212

622763905

624345899

626053991

626316016

635773093

638400137

639243890

640694914

640895642

641069871

646265722

662954864

666021200

667142448

673294333

680659133

681805562

684072935

686467850

689548867

693826417

700432967

700979152

701396819

707896065

711683452

715850455

721208038

724566628

727519965

732296055

733460287

736987409

738770182

743524718

745689033

748633000

750933995

756784872

760381504

761351745

765781568

772747259

776626108

780478695

781573644

795201606

796197105

796681362

811069874

821333548

821982127

833612100

835634091

838797152

841115097

841289207

842540523

845957040

859124078

859897938

860094766

870537530

871928101

875222192

877495250

878596691

880944293

884490603

885674660

889179264

894540831

899464944

911491962

911556704

911792575

912880613

913934388

914346146

919009385

919282658

923290558

924072448

935059178

935062985

937906269

942271379

948794948

952347361

955238821

956463762

960214114

963008528

968482883

969792559

973293227

976918955

977319822

979973260

984305166

985636580

988404694

989561241

997750406

1005202790

1006418497

1007351600

1008388599

1010949349

1011299337

1017211911

1018468762

1020729090

1022851947

1023060296

1025343129

1035965967

1048835329

1052560893

1066375003

1072643637

Respondent group

Organisation name

Submission reference number

Local authority

Aberdeenshire Council

297215771

Animal welfare NGOs

British Divers Marine Life Rescue

473585867

Animal welfare NGOs

Marine Concern

383348062

Animal welfare NGOs

Stop The Ythan Seal Cull - Ythan Seal Conservation Group

420157479

Animal welfare NGOs

Animal Concern Advice Line

825462460

Animal welfare NGOs

Cetacean Research & Rescue Unit ( CRRU)

569651535

Animal welfare NGOs

Animal Concern, Save Our Seals Fund

900244869

Animal welfare NGOs

Whale and Dolphin Conservation

1020372126

Fishing Industry

Newburgh Angling Club

546906804; 1058234297

Fishing Industry

River Ythan Trust

753580082

Fishing Industry

Usan salmon Fisheries Ltd

844712622

Fishing Industry

Salmon Net Fishing Association of Scotland

506768035

Fishing Industry

Aberdeen and District Angling Association

635823418

Community group

Foveran Community Council

640833695

Community group

Aberdeenshire Local Outdoor Access Forum

812721258; 869655544

Other Government body

Scottish Natural Heritage

694763238


Contact