Caledonian System Evaluation: Analysis of a programme for tackling domestic abuse in Scotland

Appendix C: Additional tables and figures

Table C.1: Number of men recorded in monitoring data as starting the Men's Programme, mid-September 2010 to April 2016, by hub

Hub	Number of men in monitoring data as starting men's programme
Lothian and Borders	282
Dumfries and Galloway	83
Forth Valley	170
Aberdeen	241
Ayrshire	165
Total	941

Table C.2: Number of men recorded in monitoring data as starting and completing various stages of Men's Programme - restricted to actual/potential completions as of April 2016

Stage		TOTAL	Lothian and Borders	Dumfries and Galloway	Forth Valley	Aberdeen	Ayrshire
All potential completers 1		583	157	40	117	153	116
Completed Pre-group and started Group stage	Number	479	126	36	96	136	85
	%	82%	80%	90%	82%	89%	73%
Completed Group stage and started Maintenance stage	Number	280	87	28	55	66	44
	%	48%	55%	70%	47%	43%	38%
Did not complete the full programme 2	Number	324	58	11	77	91	87
	%	56%	37%	28%	66%	59%	75%
Outcome unclear from monitoring data 3	Number	72	27	7	12	16	10
	%	12%	17%	18%	10%	10%	9%
Completed the programme successfully 4	Number	187	72	22	28	46	19
	% of all potential completers	32%	46%	55%	24%	30%	16%
	% of those with a clear recorded outcome 5	37%	55%	67%	27%	34%	18%

Notes to table:
¹ All those with a date of order up to the end March 2014 (i.e. 2 years before the monitoring data was submitted for the evaluation) OR whose date of order is missing, but whose case is no longer open as they have left the programme. Anyone whose order was within the last 2 years could still be on the programme, and could not yet have completed successfully.
² All those that are recorded as 'closed' and were NOT recorded as 'completed successfully' at Maintenance stage, plus any recorded as 'breached' or 'revoked' at Maintenance stage.
³ Any cases where order was over 2 years ago, but not recorded as 'completed successfully' and not closed.
⁴ All those with whose Maintenance stage outcome is recorded as 'completed successfully'.
⁵ All those recorded as completed successfully, divided by those completed successfully + those recorded as 'breached' or 'revoked' + those recorded as 'closed' and NOT completed successfully (i.e. excluding those whose outcome was unclear).

Table C.3: Age profile of all men starting Men's Programme

Age	% of total
16 to 18	1%
19 to 24	17%
25 to 34	44%
35 to 44	23%
45 to 54	12%
55+	3%
Base: all with date of birth data available	939

Table C.4: Ethnicity of all men starting Men's Programme

Ethnicity	% of total
White	98%
African, Caribbean or Black	0.5%
Asian, Asian Scottish or Asian British	0.4%
Mixed or multiple ethnic groups	0.3%
Other	1%
Base: all with ethnicity data available	778

Figure C.1: SARA 3 (Risk to others) at assessment and maintenance

Base: All with a SARA 3 score at assessment and maintenance stages (195)

Table C.5: Psychometric test scores at Pre-group and Maintenance stages

	Baseline range in the data	Pre Group Mean Score	Maintenance Mean Score	Change	Base
Propensity for Abusiveness Scale ( PAS)	41-170	56.4	47.2	-9.2 (-16.3%)	133
Levenson Locus of Control ( LOC)
LOC 1 - Internality	0-48	30.8	30.5	-0.3 (-1%)	132
LOC 2 - Powerful others	0-48	18.4	15.3	-3.1 (-16.8%)	132
LOC 3 - Chance	0-48	21.4	18.0	-3.4 (-15.9%)	132
Balanced Inventory of Desired Responding ( BIDR)
BIDR A - Self deception	1-100	52.2	55.1	+2.9 (+5.6%)	130
BIDR B - Impression management	1-100	50.4	50.5	+0.1 (0.2%)	130

Table C.6: Alcohol and drug problems at Pre-group and Maintenance stages stage

	Pre-group	Maintenance
Alcohol problem
Yes	81% [27]	43%
No	19%	56%
Base: all those for whom data is available at Pre-group and Maintenance	174
Drugs problem
Yes	57%	23%
No	43%	77%
Base: all those for whom data is available at Pre-group and Maintenance		175

This version ISBN 00123456789XX is current as at 01-03-2015

REVISIONS TABLE

	Date	Changes
First Published 1.0	01/01/2012	Update 1.0
Revision 1.1	15/08/2012	Update 1.1
Revision 1.2	01/12/2012	Update 1.2
Revision 2.0	18/05/2013	Update 1.3
2 nd Edition 2.0	03/03/2015	Update 2.0

UPDATES PAGE

Update 1.0	01/01/2012	First Published 1.0
Update 1.1	15/08/2012	Revision 1.1
Update 1.2	01/12/2012	Revision 1.2
Update 1.3	18/05/2013	Revision 1.3
Update 2.0	03/03/2015	2 nd Edition 2.0

Revisions Detail:

Appendix 1.0
First Published 01/01/2012

Update 1.1
Revision 1.1 15/08/2012
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut

Update 1.2
Revision 1.2 01/12/2012
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut

Update 2.0
A new edition was published on 03/03/2015 ISBN 00123456789XX

How to access background or source data

The data collected for this social research publication:

☐ cannot be made available by Scottish Government for further analysis as Scottish Government is not the data controller.