Delivering the OHCA Strategy 2015/16
Purpose of this Review
This Review reports on progress in the OHCA Strategy and is intended to stimulate further actions. The number and scale of activities since the launch of the Strategy is such that this Review cannot comprehensively report all action. Rather the focus is on particularly significant and innovative activities which are illustrative of the broader achievements. Annex 1 sets out progress by partner organisations against their commitments made in the Strategy.
The ambition for Scotland to significantly improve
outcomes requires a broad range of actions and improvements to
address all six elements of the 'augmented chain of survival'.
These comprise: Readiness; Early Recognition and Call for Help;
Defibrillation Pre-hospital resuscitation; Post Resuscitation Care
The OHCA Strategy set out aims to achieve each element.
The six elements of the 'augmented chain of survival' form the structure of this report. The main activities from 2015/16 are reported under the relevant intermediate outcomes from the Delivery Plan described below.
Source: Dobbie, F., MacIntosh, A-M. and Bauld, L. (2016) "Exploring the knowledge, attitudes, and behaviour of the general public to Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest" Edinburgh: Scottish Government. ISBN 9781785449888
Aim: To encourage a greater public awareness of 'the right thing to do' and an increased willingness to help when present as a bystander at an OHCA.
1.1 Creating a culture of bystander action
The cornerstone to improving survival and outcomes from OHCA is ordinary people being equipped and ready to carry out bystander CPR. Achieving this public 'readiness' is being driven by a coordinated, national approach intended to stimulate the culture shift required. The experience in the first year of the OHCA Strategy has highlighted that there are many organisations already training people in CPR and ready do more, and that the Scottish public are willing to get involved.
A first task for the Strategy was to establish the current position and find out the views of the people of Scotland on OHCA. A public opinion survey, Exploring the knowledge, attitudes, and behaviour of the general public to responding to OHCA provided insight and informed the planning of activities. The findings were encouraging, revealing (Dobbie, F. et al: 2016):
- Over half of the population has been trained in CPR.
- An overwhelming majority of people said that they would try CPR rather than do nothing at all.
- More than three out of four of the people surveyed agreed that everyone should be trained in CPR.
This survey and a literature review (Scottish Government, forthcoming) identified key factors which may influence an individual's response to a cardiac arrest. Some of the most important barriers to doing CPR were: fear of doing more harm or making the situation worse; fear of catching something (generally in relation to carrying out mouth to mouth ventilation); and fear of being sued. This has informed the activities for the OHCA Strategy.
1.2 Raising awareness and willingness to help
Simply not knowing how to perform CPR is one barrier to intervening. Educating people in Scotland about CPR and equipping them with the skill to carry it out is integral to achieving culture shift. By demonstrating the crucial impact of intervening immediately, busting the 'doing harm' myth and increasing confidence to respond it is possible to elevate the rate of bystander CPR in Scotland. Progressing this has been the priority in the first year of the Strategy as is demonstrated throughout this report.
2 Early Recognition
Aim: To ensure that those who witness an OHCA promptly call 999 and are enabled to carry out immediate Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation ( CPR) and use a Public Access Defibrillator ( PAD) where available.
To engender the belief amongst staff and members of the public that with effective action, OHCA can be a survivable event.
2.1 Increased public awareness of how to respond to an OHCA
All the CPR training activities provided by partners incorporate raising awareness of OHCA and the need to respond. In 2015/16 an explicit aim in delivering the OHCA Strategy was to increase public awareness at national and local community level.
2.1.1 Save a Life for Scotland
Save a Life for Scotland ( SALFS) is a partnership that has come together to increase CPR training amongst the population. It coordinates activities that raise awareness of cardiac arrest and provides CPR training and education via the range of partner organisations.
The Save a Life for Scotland partnership includes a wide range of organisations from the public and voluntary sectors:
- The Scottish Ambulance Service
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service
- Defence Medical Services
- Police Scotland
- The British Heart Foundation
- The British Red Cross
- St Andrew's First Aid
- Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland
- The Royal Life Saving Society Scotland
- Trossachs Search and Rescue
- The Resuscitation Research Group at the University of Edinburgh
and includes affiliated supporters including BASICS Scotland, NHS Scotland, Higher Education Institutions, Heartstart ( BHF) and Council representatives.
The three main aims for Save a Life for Scotland in its first year were:
- To highlight and encourage the work of groups who are already teaching CPR within their communities.
- To develop local community networks to encourage cross service collaboration in identifying communities across Scotland who have less CPR training opportunity, and to offer support.
- To coordinate larger scale events, promoting the campaign to the whole cross section of the Scottish public.
Save a Life for Scotland has had a promising start. Community resilience has been placed high on the agenda of all partner groups. Scotland is increasingly becoming a country ready and able to respond to someone suffering a cardiac arrest.
Save A Life for Scotland has recorded that in excess of 60,000 people in Scotland have learned CPR since the launch in October 2015.
These numbers are encouraging. The Save a Life for Scotland campaign in its first year has been laying the foundation for building CPR activity across the country and it is expected to report a rise in numbers year on year.
During the first year of the Strategy, Save a Life for Scotland has developed an active online presence to further its aims. The campaign website www.savealife.scot is the central portal for information and activity where the public can access information on bystander CPR and search for local CPR training. Partner organisations can post news on ongoing activity and share CPR resources and information.
Social media is key to communication and there is a growing public following via Facebook (Save a Life for Scotland) and Twitter (@savealifescot, #savealifescot). These are used to raise partners awareness of CPR activity nationally as well as signposting members of the public to forthcoming opportunities for CPR training. Vimeo, YouTube and Flickr sites are also actively used to publicise Save a Life for Scotland with videos and images telling survivor stories, case studies and showcasing partner activities.
Awareness raising via the media is invaluable to educate people on OHCA and encourage bystander CPR, and indeed to save lives. Previous successful media campaigns have included the British Heart Foundation's 'Hands Only CPR / Vinny Jones - Push Hard and Fast'. Building on this, Save a Life for Scotland is raising the profile of groups already working in communities and building additional capacity for teaching CPR and defibrillation awareness to members of the public.
Save a Life for Scotland has also capitalised on public awareness-raising opportunities through collaboration with other organisations committed to enhancing community resilience. Organisations such as 'Positively Scottish' and 'Living it Up' have recognised and highlighted the campaign as have local press by reporting on the work of local community groups and their impact. These stories are especially powerful when lives have been saved through CPR being delivered promptly by members of the public.
Picture Credit: Claire Fleck photography
Larger scale events have also provided invaluable opportunities to relay the Save a Life for Scotland message to a broad cross section of the Scottish public. During the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo, Save a Life for Scotland had a stand to raise awareness of the campaign and provide CPR training. Volunteers from partners and supporter organisations worked together each night of the three weeks of the Tattoo to deliver this. In all over 1500 learned CPR. Cards highlighting the campaign and signposting opportunities to receive training were also distributed.
Castle Concerts were receptive and played a promotional video at the Edinburgh Castle event featuring Runrig in advance of their performance, with a great public reach. View the video here: https://vimeo.com/175869017.
A notable collaborative initiative is by Save a Life for Scotland and Westquarter Primary School, Falkirk. This produced three short videos to inform people of the importance of bystander CPR. These videos have been made available to be used within schools for CPR education but also have a wider audience appeal and have been shared across social medial platforms. They cover:
- Key messages around current survival.
- 'You don't need to be a superhero to do CPR, you just need to be you' a CPR demonstration.
You don't need to be a superhero to do CPR, you just need to be you
This link will take you to the video, which is hosted on Vimeo. The Scottish Government is not responsible for the content of this site.
Key Messages around current survival
This link will take you to the video, which is hosted on Vimeo. The Scottish Government is not responsible for the content of this site.
'Mythbusting' around the fears identified from the Omnibus survey were also addressed in a fun yet informative series of videos.
This link will take you to the video, which is hosted on Vimeo. The Scottish Government is not responsible for the content of this site.
2.1.2 CPR in SFRS Home Fire Safety Visits - Activities 2017 and beyond
The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service ( SFRS) are taking forward a unique initiative to raise awareness and willingness to help in OHCA. The SFRS carries out approximately 70,000 Home Fire Safety Visits ( HFSV) across Scotland annually, directly engaging with at least this number of people in their own homes. The majority of these visits focus on fire related risks and preventative measures, however an increasing number are assessing other risks in the home associated with wider health and wellbeing.
Building on this development, an extension of the HFSV, presents the opportunity to provide people with a range of measures which can equip them to assist someone experiencing an OHCA. In taking this forward it is proposed to carry out trials within the areas covered by the following three stations, one in each SFRS Delivery Area:
- Arbroath in the North.
- Galashiels in the East.
- Cumbernauld in the West.
Work to plan HFSV including OHCA and CPR awareness elements has already commenced and these will go live from early 2017.
2.2 Improved systems and training in Ambulance Control Centres
The Ambulance Control Centre ( ACC) call handlers are at the frontline in recognising a cardiac arrest and giving the best guidance to bystanders on how to respond. The 2015 public opinion survey found that most people (82%) said they would be confident to administer CPR if a 999 call handler talked them through it. Other evidence shows that telephone CPR (T-CPR) by ACC handlers can increase and improve CPR administered.
When ACC receive a call identified as cardiac arrest a core action by handlers is to have a bystander commence CPR immediately. They continue to talk them through the process, providing reassurance and encouragement. This can be key to getting CPR started when a bystander does not take the initiative to do so. T-CPR can improve the quality of the CPR, by setting the rhythm to push. T-CPR requires skills: to communicate what is required and to persuade reluctant bystanders and support people anxious about responding.
The Scottish Ambulance Service's OHCA training and handling has improved the response and support. The Scottish Ambulance Service is also working to secure recognition as an accredited Centre of Excellence for the Ambulance Control Centres and the standard of compliance is supported through audit.
Aim: To increase the rate of bystander CPR and to equip an additional 500,000 people with CPR skills by 2020 and create a nation of life savers.
defibrillation are paramount to improving outcomes for people who
have a cardiac arrest. It is internationally recognised that
improve the chances of survival by between two and seven times.
People trained in
more likely to know how to react to an
to start CPR.
3.1 Increased CPR training offered to public
Equipping people with CPR skills has been a priority in this first phase in the delivery of the Strategy. The focus was on offering CPR training to those who have never had the opportunity to learn this lifesaving skill but also to those who sought the opportunity to have their skills refreshed.
3.1.1 Save a Life for Scotland
Save a Life for Scotland is leading on CPR training. They have harnessed and added to the a wealth of CPR training already being delivered through many organisations including public services, voluntary organisations and volunteers. The following illustrate this work.
Save a Life for Scotland was officially launched on 16th October 2015 in Edinburgh, with simultaneous satellite events held across the country. The launch was held on the same date as the annual European Restart a Heart Day.
The launch event brought together all the partners under the one banner and achieved an estimated 3,500 members of the public learning CPR across Scotland on the one day. Most participants signalled their greater commitment to undertaking training in CPR and their willingness to perform basic life support by pledging 'I'll do it' across their photograph.
It was, 'The start of a movement to train 500,000 Scots in CPR by 2020 and save 1000 lives,' (Save a Life for Scotland (2015) SALFS Launch Report).
The events were:
In Edinburgh there were 50 CPR trainers from partner organisations such as Scottish Ambulance Service, Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, Army, St Andrews First Aid and Trossachs Search and Rescue. They trained over 1400 people in a marquee in Princes St. and including including Maureen Watt, MSP Minister for Mental Health.
Heartstart, BASICS and Community First Responder groups provided
events in Aberdeen (50 attendees), Neilston (60 attendees), Orkney,
(11 attendees), Bathgate, Lanarkshire and Perth.
Over Scotland 70 Fire Stations across Scotland opened their doors to the public and provided 'hands-on' CPR training to local communities (North region had over 1000 attendances).
Scottish Ambulance Service held events at National HQ, the Scottish Borders, West Lothian (150 attendees) and Glasgow Centre (600 attendees).
Glasgow Science Centre with Glasgow Dental School provided training in the Glasgow Science Centre (175 attendees).
The launch report contains further details and is available from: http://savealife.scot/resources/The-Launch-Report-16th-October-2015.pdf.
See a short video of the launch at: https://vimeo.com/176767370.
CPR training provision has been by:
- First Responder and Community Resilience Groups, supported by the Scottish Ambulance Service.
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service opening of 356 community fire and rescue stations to be used as training venues, using Call Push Rescue training kits provided by BHF.
- The British Heart Foundation provided Call Push Rescue training kits to 108 secondary schools and continues to support 279 Heartstart schools enabling them to train approximately 40,000 school children in the last 12 months across Scotland.
- Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland have also produced two excellent Health Sketch videos addressing fears around CPR and an animated demonstration.
Whilst much CPR training is in schools or community halls, St Andrew's First Aid have been visiting a number of shopping malls across Glasgow with strong public engagement. Scottish Fire and Rescue Service also reached the public in Aberdeen Union Square Shopping Centre, teaching CPR. St Andrew's First Aid has been working in partnership with the Young Farmers and Mamas and Papas to deliver CPR sessions, and in 2016 CPR training has been delivered to a wide demographic from the central belt to the north of Scotland, reaching approximately 2,000 people.
Trossachs Search and Rescue provides free CPR & Automated External Defibrillator ( AED) training, with ongoing work with local businesses.
At the Royal Highland Show, Save a Life for Scotland were represented by East Neuk First Responders, supported by Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland. For four days, members of the public stopped to learn CPR.
In June partners took the opportunity to train attendees at the annual NHS Scotland Conference in Glasgow. The training space was consistently busy and great links made for future activities.
One of the challenges of the first year has been in finding and reaching those already working hard to promote CPR training in their communities. Work continues to develop a clear picture of existing 'local champions' to continue to build this network. The continued aim is to develop existing CPR training resources available within Scotland at a local level. Real sustainable change can only occur when local communities come together to learn.
3.1.2 Teaching CPR in Primary and Secondary Education
Everyone can learn CPR. Even the youngest can learn to recognise when someone is unwell and seek help. In countries that have successfully improved OHCA survival, training and educating young people in CPR has been at the heart of their strategy. Working with schools to support CPR education is a key priority for Save a Life for Scotland.
In many schools across Scotland CPR training is embedded and is part of the school's culture. There are examples of innovative approaches such as peer learning - training older children to teach younger groups. These schemes have been developed under initiatives such as The British Heart Foundation's Heartstart and Call Push Rescue programmes, St Andrew's First Aid, The British Red Cross, The Royal Life Saving Society and Lucky 2 B Here. Save a Life for Scotland's aim is to link up schools seeking help with those groups already actively training in their area.
There are some schools where no CPR training is provided and over the five years of the Strategy the aim is to support as many schools in Scotland as possible to teach CPR to their pupils. To achieve this Save a Life for Scotland is already working with Education Scotland and has created a pack for schools outlining resources available from all partners. This will be a central starting point for schools and youth groups seeking CPR training. These resources are available on Education Scotland GLOW website and also via http://savealife.scot/resources/The-Launch-Report-16th-October-2015.pdf.
The Community School of Auchterarder: In June 2016, the Community School of Auchterarder taught CPR to over 500 pupils, staff and members of the community in one day. It was organised by the Janitor and Community Responder, Alan Moffat.
A review by the Head Teacher, Stuart Clyde, can be viewed at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TyZoVhKQW9g.
3.1.3 Young People - Activities 2017 and beyond
In conjunction with the support for schools, Save a Life for Scotland is working with Young Scot to develop a social media CPR survey and campaign running from November 2016 - May 2017. The experience Young Scot holds in creating campaigns specifically for young people is invaluable. The first stage of this work is to find out about young people's knowledge and experience of CPR education and training, including how and where they would like to learn this essential life-saving skill.
The campaign running from January 2017 will include awareness and education via social media and link directly to the Young Scot awards system.
Aim: To reduce inequalities in survival after OHCA
3.1.4 Reducing Health inequalities
International research shows that bystander CPR rates are higher in less deprived and more rural areas. Work from the British Red Cross has also identified lower response where there is a larger proportion of ethnic minority groups. There is work underway to actively engage communities where bystander CPR rates are lower in order to raise these.
St Andrew's First Aid project Bandage15 involved identifying young people in areas of high deprivation, obtaining funding, and providing first aid learning in particular CPR, which is then cascaded by peer facilitators. The overarching aim was to target young people who would be unlikely to access CPR training, and enabling them to be confident in using their skills in their communities.
Police Scotland have committed to training all their Youth Volunteers in CPD and defibrillation awareness. These young people are disproportionately recruited from areas of high deprivation. Work is ongoing to help develop this initiative further and link in with the wider Save a Life for Scotland strategy.
3.1.5 Reducing health inequalities - Activities 2017 and beyond
Inspiring Scotland runs the Link Up programme which helps people living in areas of multiple deprivation in Scotland develop groups and run activities by and for communities. Save a Life for Scotland, with Inspiring Scotland, will work via these established groups to equip people with CPR skills during winter 2016/17. This venture will be supported by Scottish Fire and Rescue Services and Scottish Ambulance Service using equipment provided from the British Heart Foundation.
3.2 Community groups fully engaged in OHCA Agenda
3.2.1 First Responders
First Responders are volunteers who are trained by, and work with, the Scottish Ambulance Service to respond to medical emergencies while the blue light services are on their way. First Responders are equipped to deal with cardiac arrest in their local community. They increase the potential of a rapid and effective response to improve outcomes for people suffering an OHCA. First responders also deliver community-based CPR training.
Currently in Scotland there are 135 First Responder Schemes comprising 1,500 volunteers. The Scottish Ambulance Service continues to support and build the First Responder Network. First responders are central to community resilience and the ability of communities to help themselves, and do so as part of an integrated network of support and care appropriate to their needs.
3.3 Increase in partner training in CPR
The Strategy has encouraged some public sector partners to refresh the CPR training offered across their own organisations.
Police Scotland has trained all new recruits, 590 regular officers and 69 Special Constables to date, at the Police Scotland college in CPR/ AED awareness since October 2015. All serving Police Scotland officers have had refresher training using the BHF Heartstart Module that is enhanced at Annual Operational Safety Training recertification, with this completed by 8612 police officers this year.
The Scottish Government offer of CPR training was taken up by 437 staff in Edinburgh, Aberdeen, Glasgow and Inverness.
3.4 Improved reporting of number of people trained in CPR
Recording the numbers of people in Scotland who have learned CPR is essential to know progress in achieving the aim of equipping an additional 500,000 people with the lifesaving skill of CPR by 2020. In addition to tracking progress against this key aim this information can be used to highlight parts of Scotland where additional support for CPR training may be required.
Two methods to obtain information on numbers trained are being used:
(i) Submission of numbers trained are being used to Save a Life for Scotland.
During this first year, numbers have begun to be reported by partners as they become available. A specialised database has been designed and will be operational by November 2016 for all partners and supporters to log training activity which should improve accuracy.
(ii) Number and proportion of the population trained in CPR.
From 2017 the Scottish Health Survey ( SHeS) will include questions on CPR training. The results available from 2018 will be the source for: number of additional people trained, the proportion of the population, and the geographic and socio-economic characteristics of people trained in CPR. This will meet the need for high quality national data on the spread and impact of training. The intention is to include these and further questions in the revised SHeS from 2018.
3.5 Increased bystander CPR
It is the rapid, correct intervention by bystanders at an OHCA where the greatest gains in survival and best outcomes will be achieved. Many elements in the Strategy are intended to support this happening - e.g. CPR training, willingness to intervene and culture change. It is therefore critical to know if these are having the desired impact. Work is underway to understand and improve the current quality of bystander CPR data from the Scottish Ambulance Service in order to establish a baseline for monitoring trends over time and evidence the impact of bystander CPR on survival rates.
Aims: To rapidly deploy available assets which routinely carry defibrillators - ambulances and others where appropriate such as Scottish Fire and Rescue Service and First Responders.
To put in place effective arrangements to ensure that Public Access Defibrillators ( PADS) are mapped, maintained and accessible to the public.
Defibrillation delivers a therapeutic dose of electrical energy to the heart. It is the only successful treatment available for the most common heart rhythm disturbance causing OHCA - Ventricular Fibrillation ( VF). Defibrillation works with CPR and is most effective the earlier it is performed. There are three main ways of proactively getting a defibrillator as rapidly as possible to the person having the OHCA:
- Dispatching emergency services vehicles that carry defibrillators; ambulances and SFRS vehicles.
- Dispatching volunteers with defibrillators, e.g. Community First responders.
- Sending a bystander at the scene to a publicly available defibrillator ( PAD) whilst CPR is delivered.
4.1 Increased co-responding to OHCA by Scottish Fire and Rescue Service and Scottish Ambulance Service
In November 2015 the Scottish Ambulance Service and Scottish Fire and Rescue Service commenced trialling co-responding to OHCAs from ten stations:
- Musselburgh, Hawick, Coldstream & Lauder.
- Falkirk, Livingston, Bathgate and Linlithgow.
- Turriff and Maud.
The trials involve simultaneous dispatch of both Scottish Ambulance Service and Scottish Fire and Rescue Service resources to OHCA incidents. These are informed by international evidence that improved outcomes are associated with early CPR and defibrillation. By building on the existing assets of public services to harness their strengths and resources the aim is to reduce response times to OHCA, particularly in rural areas. Co-responding builds on a history of these services working together to respond to incidents and, for the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, it resonated with developments already in train.
Initial data indicates that response and intervention by the SFRS to OHCA incidents has contributed to a reduction in response times and improved patient outcomes. The evaluation is due later in 2016 and this will inform a plan for further co-responding roll out.
The full video co-responder video can be viewed at: https://vimeo.com/172116742
4.1.1 Co-responding by Police Scotland - Activities 2017 and beyond
Police Scotland are also committed to involvement in co-responding to OHCA. Later this year a trial of defibrillators in roads policing units in Grampian will commence and further roll out will be considered following the evaluation of this project.
4.2 Location of all Public Access Defibrillators ( PADs) in Scotland made available on Scottish Ambulance Service system
4.2.1 PAD mapping onto Scottish Ambulance Service System
Public Access Defibrillators ( PADs) that can be used by bystanders in OHCA are already in place in a variety of locations across Scotland. The Scottish Ambulance Service are working to make this information available on the system used in Ambulance Control Centres by call handlers, so they can rapidly deploy PADs in the case of an OHCA.
Achieving this involves a number of linked and ongoing tasks by the Scottish Ambulance Service to identify, map and maintain PADs. A large number of PADs are already known to the Scottish Ambulance Service and are ready to be uploaded onto the new system. In addition, the Scottish Ambulance Service website has recently been updated with a section where members of the public can upload information about PAD sites.
The enhanced system data on mapped PADs in Ambulance Control Centres will be operational from April 2017.
Aim: To strive to ensure that communities in remote and rural locations have equity of treatment for OHCA
The Sandpiper Wildcat project is a two-year quality improvement project aimed at improving outcomes from OHCA in remote and rural Grampian. The project looks at ways of decreasing the time from 999 call to defibrillation. The project will focus on early CPR and defibrillation by strategically placing 100 additional defibrillators with community responders. The location of the defibrillators is based on analysis of the location of cardiac arrests in Grampian. Three Scottish Ambulance Service paramedics have been seconded to the project for its duration. The project is due to go live in winter 2016 following a programme of training and education.
5 Pre-Hospital Resuscitation
Aims: To ensure high quality resuscitation is delivered consistently in the pre-hospital care environment.
To ensure that patients - either during or after cardiac arrest - are taken to a location with appropriate post cardiac arrest care.
To ensure that patients treated in hospital following OHCA receive optimal care.
5.1 Improved Scottish Ambulance Service response to OHCA calls
The Scottish Ambulance Service dispatch at least three responders to all OHCA calls where and when possible. Between February 2015 and August 2016, 6595 (88.1% of the total number of OHCA calls) saw at least three responders in attendance.
5.2 Enhanced training and skills of Scottish Ambulance Service crew attending OHCAs
Following the successful operation of the specialist Resuscitation Rapid Response Unit ( 3RU) model in Edinburgh sites, it will be rolled out in other urban areas. The model will commence in Glasgow this year and Aberdeen early next year.
The Association of Ambulance Chief Executives ( AACE) currently recommend that all OHCA resuscitation attempts have a team leader. The 3RU training course and Standard Operating Procedures have been written to reflect this recommendation and are awaiting approval by Scottish Ambulance Service clinical advisory group. This will provide 3RU paramedics with the knowledge and enhanced skills necessary to provide leadership and enhanced clinical care to the victims of OHCA. A programme of education, debrief and feedback will be rolled out concurrently to all staff in these areas during the 3RU implementation, with the aim of demonstrating improved outcomes.
5.3 Minimisation of inappropriate resuscitation
The updated NHS Scotland Do Not Attempt Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation policy was released in September 2016. This policy has been made available to all ambulance staff via the Scottish Ambulance Service intranet site. The OHCA Clinical Effectiveness Lead plans to develop an e-learning module in 2017 to ensure all staff understand how to apply the policy.
5.4 Scottish Ambulance Service Defibrillators replaced
The Scottish Ambulance Service's plan is for the procurement of replacement defibrillators to take place in 2018.
5.5 Strengthened and improved transfer of OHCA patients to hospital
In accordance with the AACE best practice recommendations, the Scottish Ambulance Service is developing a post-Return of Spontaneous Circulation (post- ROSC) clinical guideline to enhance patient care. The intention is that post- ROSC patients will only be transported to regional cardiac arrest centres.
6 Post Resuscitation Rehabilitation and Aftercare
Aims: To ensure post event care and support is available to patients and their families/carers after OHCA.
To ensure that bystanders and others impacted by OHCA are supported after the event.
6.1 Improving support provided to individuals and their families after OHCA
With a projected increase in those surviving OHCA, comes a need to provide appropriate and timely aftercare and rehabilitation. The care delivered to those experiencing sudden heart related events such heart attack has improved significantly over the last 30 years. Key to the recovery process has been access to cardiac rehabilitation programmes. Historically, these have been restricted to specific patient groups. In order to address the needs of the wider heart population, a national cardiac rehabilitation 'champion' was employed in 2014, with the primary aim being to promote the modernisation of services across Scotland. As part of the OHCA strategy, the partners have begun working with cardiac rehabilitation and other relevant aftercare services to raise awareness of the needs OHCA survivors and enhance future care.
Survivors need more than just cardiac rehabilitation. When a person survives an OHCA the whole family is affected. Understanding and addressing the needs of the survivor and their families, requires effective multi-disciplinary working. Across the course of the Strategy, partners such as Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland and the Resuscitation Research Group at the University of Edinburgh will seek opportunities to develop and evaluate innovative care pathways, which integrate existing services including cardiology, psychology and community services.
Having conducted a variety of activities which highlighted the needs of the OHCA population, Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland agreed, in 2016, to begin the process of addressing gaps within current provision through the production of two online resources. The aim of these is to provide information, support and advice during the rehabilitation and aftercare phase. The online modules will be available from autumn 2017.
One of the modules will focus on the needs of survivors, their family members and those who have been bereaved. Although the principal focus of any resuscitation attempt must be the survival of the victim, it is essential to consider the long-term consequences that the event may have on the quality of life of the individual and their family. Care should extend to address the needs of those bereaved. The resource design and development will be led by individuals who have personal experience of OHCA.
6.2 Improving support for OHCA responders, co-responders and bystanders
A second online module will be specifically designed for those involved in the care and management of those affected by OHCA. The number of individuals and organisations involved in responding to OHCA has extended and expanded greatly, with Scottish Fire & Rescue staff, Police Scotland staff, First Responders and trained members of the public increasingly involved in events. With these changes comes the need to fully appreciate the effect that OHCA may have on responders and design appropriate support. During the resource design process, the role of peer support will be explored and built into the resources, where appropriate.
Further research into the impact of being involved as a bystander at an OHCA is being carried out by RRG. The First Responder Study, funded by the Resuscitation Council, UK is conducting a detailed survey of the impact and aftermath of being involved in OHCA, whether as a family member or complete stranger. This work is well underway and should be completed in early 2017.
Gregor Newton and Jeremy Southam both had OHCA in 2014 and recovered.
7 Culture and context
Aim: To collect, analyse and report accurate and complete data in order to inform decision making and improve outcomes after cardiac arrest.
7.1 Registry Data and reporting
Data collection is widely recognised as an essential foundation to systematic improvement of OHCA outcomes. A range of evidence will be used to inform and monitor the OHCA Strategy.
The OHCA Data Linkage Project is linking OHCA data from the Scottish Ambulance Service with hospital data and deaths data to evidence the 'Chain of Survival'. This Review is the first time that the main findings from the OHCA Data Linkage Project are reported.
Subject to permissions from the various organisations involved in the project, it is hoped that from 2017 co-responder data from the Scottish Fire & Rescue Service and then Police Scotland will be incorporated into the OHCA Data Linkage Project. This will enable examination of evidence on the impact of the contribution from the Scottish Fire & Rescue Service and Police Scotland on the 'augmented chain of survival'.
This is a pilot project and the longer term aim is to work with OHCA Strategy partners and data providers to develop an ongoing OHCA Registry. The establishment of the Registry will enable researchers to analyse the patient-specific and system-specific factors influencing survival, and to identify areas for improvement in the 'Chain of Survival'. The formation of a OHCA Registry in Scotland is widely recognised as an essential foundation to systematic improvement of OHCA outcomes, as has been demonstrated in other countries with their own OHCA Registries. This will also continue to provide the metrics for monitoring the progress and impact of the Strategy. A more detailed analytical report will be published in early 2017 and thereafter, at least annually.
* Data planned to be incorporated in due course, subject to permissions.
Aim: To improve and simplify the capture of data by Scottish Ambulance Service to support clinical care and contribute to the cardiac arrest strategy.
Scottish Ambulance Service staff collect the data for learning, improving and monitoring OHCA. They are committed to developing this to drive improvements.
Aim: To develop and maintain an environment which supports innovation and research leading to improved outcomes for OHCA.
Partners in the Strategy have led and been involved in a number of major events for learning and knowledge exchange. These include:
- Scottish Cardiac Arrest Symposium.
- European Resuscitation Academy.
The Scottish Cardiac Arrest Symposium, held in June 2016, included a presentation from Save a Life for Scotland about the campaign and the Primary 1 class of Westquarter Primary School in Falkirk brought a confident and powerful challenge to those committed to improving outcomes from cardiac arrest. Watch their presentation here:
The RRG have many research projects in collaboration with partners:
- Edinburgh University Psychology Dept: An investigation into the communication patterns of the resuscitation team.
- Scottish Ambulance Service: Using body worn video cameras to analyse team performance in OHCA. Funded by Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland.
- NHS Lothian. Resuscitation of OHCA in the Emergency Department. A video audit.
- Scottish Centre for Social Marketing.
- Scottish Government.
- International collaborators e.g. Steve Brooks.
- RRG and Scottish Ambulance Service partners in the Global Resuscitation Alliance.