Privacy Impact Assessment Report
NHS Model Complaints Handling Procedure
The Scottish Health Council’s report ‘ Listening and Learning: how feedback, comments, concerns and complaints can improve NHS services in Scotland’ made a number of recommendations relating to complaints handling, including a direct recommendation that the SPSO’s Complaints Standards Authority ( CSA) lead on the development of a revised standardised complaints handling procedure ( CHP) for NHS Scotland. The report recommended that the national dataset that is collected about complaints and feedback locally and reported nationally to Information Services Division should be reviewed and refreshed in line with a newly modelled process to ensure that the focus is on demonstrating learning and improvement, alongside effective complaints processes.
In January 2015 the Scottish Government set out its plans for the CSA to work with NHS Boards to develop this revised model CHP and associated information materials. Following this, the planned changes were explored at an executive master class on ‘Listening and Learning’, and through a series of workshops for senior charge nurses, team leaders and managers, in Edinburgh, Glasgow, Aberdeen and Inverness.
Based on these discussions, proposals for taking forward the recommendations included:
- Developing a model complaints handling procedure ( CHP) for all NHS Boards and health service providers to adapt and adopt. This would build on the Patient Rights (Scotland) Act 2011 and the Scottish Government’s existing ‘Can I Help You’ ( CIHY) guidance, but would essentially take CIHY a stage further with a detailed practical template for use across the NHS.
- Within this model CHP the existing process should be amended to bring it in line with that operating in other public service sectors through the SPSO’s model CHP. This would involve the addition of a five working day frontline resolution stage to the current 20 working day stage for investigations, replacing the current three working day provision for early resolution which is contained within the single stage 20 working days. This will bring a sharper focus to the early resolution of relatively straightforward complaints. Provision would be made for complex complaints to go straight to the investigation stage without the need for attempts at early resolution. There will also be benefits in terms of aligning the process more closely with local authorities and the Scottish Government’s proposed arrangements for health and social care and social work complaints, which will start to address the current differences in approach to complaints handling across integrated health and social care services.
Given this reworking of existing processes and procedures, it is appropriate to consider the privacy impact of these changes, alongside a reconsideration of the impact of existing processes, particularly in light of the sensitive nature of information often contained within complaints correspondence.
Privacy impact assessment ( PIA) screening questions
A set of screening questions was used to help decide the scope and focus of the PIA. We adapted these based on an examination of the privacy issues that were considered as part of the work of the steering group and sub-groups convened to progress the revision of the complaints handling procedure.
The screening questions and analysis are included at Annex A.
The information flows
The Patient Rights (Feedback, Comments, Concerns and Complaints (Scotland) Directions 2012 set out, at Direction 6 (‘Requirement to Deal with Complaints’), what information must be included in the written record of a complaint. The CIHY guidance makes clear (at 184.108.40.206) that all complains, even those that are resolved early without the need for a detailed investigation, should be recorded as normal to support organisational learning. Under the revised procedure, staff should ensure that all complaints continue to be recorded, even those resolved at stage one, within five working days (although these do not require an acknowledgement or a written report of the investigation to be sent to the person making the complaint). The requirement to record information about the complaint will revised as follows, in line with SPSO minimum requirements:
- the patient's name and address
- the date the complaint was received
- the nature of the complaint
- how the complaint was received
- the service the complaint refers to
- the date the complaint was closed at the frontline resolution stage (where appropriate)
- the date the complaint was escalated to the investigation stage (where appropriate)
- action taken at front resolution stage (where appropriate)
- action taken at the investigation stage (where appropriate)
- the date the complaint was closed at the investigation stage (where appropriate)
- the outcome of the complaint at the frontline resolution stage
- the outcome of the complaint at the investigation stage
- the underlying cause of the complaint and any remedial action taken.
NHS Boards and their health service providers have structured systems in place for recording complaints, their outcomes and any resulting action. As part of the review process, a set of Key Performance Indicators ( KPIs) were developed by the Recording and Reporting Sub-Group of the NHS Scotland Model Complaint Handling Procedure (“ MCHP”) Steering Group, These indicators support the stronger focus, in the revised procedure, on organisational learning and improvement as well as providing timely and thorough response to the person making a complaint.
If, subsequently, the complaint is referred to the Ombudsman, this may result in a request for all relevant papers and other information to be provided in good time to the Ombudsman’s office. Complaints records should be kept separate from health records, subject only to the need to record information which is strictly relevant to the patient’s health in their health record. These documents should be managed with regard to the current Scottish Government Records Management Code of Practice.
The NHS Scotland Model Complaint Handling Procedure (“ MCHP”) Steering Group created the Recording and Reporting Sub-group to:-
- Provide overall project governance for data recording and reporting aspects of the project; and
- Develop an approved approach to data recording and reporting in line with SPSO requirements, and consistent with other sectors in support of MCHP.
The expected output of the sub-group was “ an agreed, assured and responsive data recording and reporting approach, including key performance indicators and appropriate tools to support it”. Complaints officers from NHS Scotland as well as colleagues from Scottish Government and from the Information Services Division (“ ISD”) of NSS were invited to join the sub-group, in order that the output would reflect good practice and concerns.
Privacy issues have been considered as part of the work of the NHS Scotland Model Complaint Handling Procedure (“ MCHP”) Steering Group and Recording and Reporting Sub-group. In addition, these issues were considered by a workshop convened to develop the EQIA and CRWIA for the project.
Record of the PIA outcomes and integrate the outcomes back into the project plan
The revision of the procedure involves a greater emphasis on early, local resolution, wherever appropriate, so it is important that the requirements of the revised processes are clear, both to practitioners recording and to those making the complaint.
Detailed practitioner training will therefore be developed, to support staff to implement the procedure correctly, as will clear and accessible awareness-raising materials for patients, families and carers.
Specific elements of the NHS model complaints handling procedure, including the revised recording and reporting requirements, will be tested in two Board areas ahead of the proposed implementation date of 1 April. This ‘early testing’ will help identify any emerging issues in relation to the recording and reporting of complaints data, and any additional training requirements.
The privacy impacts of the proposed changes to the NHS complaints procedure will be monitored during this period of early testing and reviewed again in November 2017.
Contacts and review
Blythe Robertson, Healthcare Quality & Strategy, 0131 244 1773, firstname.lastname@example.org